Over the time, there’s been a fair bit of airtime on Twitter as to the evils of grading. I’m not sure exactly what the arguments were against grading, but just that it was no longer the thing to do.
As a student whose entire secondary schooling (apart from year 12) was based purely on a pass/fail assessment, I can say that the lack of grading resulted in a lack of motivation for me to do my best.
For the first few terms in year 7, I carried on with my primary school ethos to do my best as I loved learning. But seeing other students, who rarely did any work and any they scratched together to hand in was pretty awful, get the same grade as me who’d spent lots of time and effort to do my very best was pretty soul destroying.
So from then on I did the minimal; just enough to get a pass. I was ill prepared for HSC where exams, grades and marks were all that mattered. The same went for university. However, the system of grades at year 12 and Uni meant that my philosophy changed back to trying my very best.
Anyway, apparently my views are anachronistic and certainly unfashionable. But what I want to know is how does gaming for learning, where games give players instant feedback, scores, access to levels, access to resources and even leaderboards be good and even desirable for people who are against grading? Don’t get me wrong, I have used gaming for learning to great success and believe that in fact, the instant feedback, scores, etc. are one of the things that motivates people to play. Why else do so many businesses now try to incorporate gamification? Badges, leader boards, mayors in FourSquare anyone?
I am not a fan of class rankings (which to me = gaming leaderboards) as students will never collaborate if they are ranked against each other. (Rather like how teachers will stop collaborating with each other if performance pay is introduced. A group does the work but only one get rewarded.) However, I do see that grades = scores are a motivation. Game players are always trying for a better score, motivated to improve. How is that different from grading?
So I’d like someone who is against grading but for gaming to explain to me why one is bad and unacceptable and one is good and desirable.